This is a compelling Scenario B โ it's essentially a Scenario A home with one structural miss: the lot at 3,840 sqft falls 660 sqft short of the 4,500 minimum. Every other Scenario A box is checked and then some: 5 beds, 4.5 baths, 3,315 sqft of living space, open-concept main floor, 2-car alley-loaded garage, lower-level ADU, and primary suite upstairs. It's also a brand-new 2025 build by McCullough Architects in Loyal Heights โ your single highest-priority target neighborhood.
The lot constraint is real: at 3,840 sqft, this is an urban-tight footprint. The listing references a "large, fenced front yard," which may mean the primary outdoor space is front-of-house โ not ideal for private kid play or backyard entertaining. Worth touring specifically to walk the yard and understand how it actually feels. The $2,249,000 ask is also $49K above the Scenario B ceiling, though the location and new-construction quality arguably justify a premium.
Verdict: Tour this one. Loyal Heights location, open floor plan, ADU, and full Scenario A spec (minus the lot) is a hard combination to beat at this price point. The lot is the one real concern โ let the yard tell the story in person.